HR guide
Incapacity in South Africa: ill health and poor performance
Incapacity is the route for when someone can't meet the standard, rather than won't. It covers long-term or repeated illness and injury, and genuine inability to do the work despite trying. It's a supportive, no-fault process, and it's separate from discipline.
No commitment to kick off a search.
Incapacity or discipline?
| Incapacity | Discipline | |
|---|---|---|
| The question | Can they do it? | Will they do it? |
| Typical cases | Long-term illness, repeated genuine sickness, a skills gap despite effort | Ignoring instructions, poor timekeeping, mis-prioritising, dishonesty |
| Approach | Support, adjustments, training and time | Warnings and, if it continues, a hearing |
Many cases are a mix. We'll agree the right route with you at the start and say so clearly to the employee. See misconduct vs poor work performance.
Ill health or injury
- Get the facts: medical evidence of the condition, how long it's likely to last and what the person can do
- Consult the employee, and their representative if they want one, throughout
- Consider adjustments: different hours, reduced duties, a phased return or a different role
- Decide whether the incapacity is temporary or permanent. Temporary absence usually means waiting and supporting
- Only if nothing reasonable works, and the absence can't be accommodated, consider ending employment, after a hearing
Paid sick leave applies first. Beyond it, leave is unpaid, and the employee may be able to claim illness benefits from UIF.
Poor work performance despite genuine effort
- Set out the standard clearly and show where it isn't being met
- Find out why, and give the training, guidance and tools needed
- Allow a reasonable time to improve, with regular, documented check-ins
- If it still isn't working, consider alternatives such as a different role, then a hearing before any decision
How Scaled handles it
As the legal employer, Scaled runs the process: we gather medical evidence, hold the consultations and keep the records, while you tell us what the role needs and what flexibility you have. Tell us early about long absences or a skills gap, so support can start sooner.
Trusted by growing UK businesses









Frequently asked questions
Can I dismiss someone for being ill in South Africa?+
Only as a last resort, after investigating, consulting, considering adjustments and allowing reasonable time. Short, genuine illness is covered by sick leave.
Is a performance improvement plan the same as incapacity?+
It's the core of the poor-performance incapacity route: a clear standard, support and time to improve.
Who pays during long-term illness?+
Paid sick leave applies first. After that, leave is unpaid and the employee may claim UIF illness benefits.
Ready to hire world-class South African talent?
No upfront cost. No commitment to kick off a search. Free replacements guaranteed.