Get Scaled

HR guide

Incapacity in South Africa: ill health and poor performance

Incapacity is the route for when someone can't meet the standard, rather than won't. It covers long-term or repeated illness and injury, and genuine inability to do the work despite trying. It's a supportive, no-fault process, and it's separate from discipline.

No commitment to kick off a search.

Incapacity or discipline?

IncapacityDiscipline
The questionCan they do it?Will they do it?
Typical casesLong-term illness, repeated genuine sickness, a skills gap despite effortIgnoring instructions, poor timekeeping, mis-prioritizing, dishonesty
ApproachSupport, adjustments, training and timeWarnings and, if it continues, a hearing

Many cases are a mix. We'll agree the right route with you at the start and say so clearly to the employee. See misconduct vs poor work performance.

Ill health or injury

  1. Get the facts: medical evidence of the condition, how long it's likely to last and what the person can do
  2. Consult the employee, and their representative if they want one, throughout
  3. Consider adjustments: different hours, reduced duties, a phased return or a different role
  4. Decide whether the incapacity is temporary or permanent. Temporary absence usually means waiting and supporting
  5. Only if nothing reasonable works, and the absence can't be accommodated, consider ending employment, after a hearing

Paid sick leave applies first. Beyond it, leave is unpaid, and the employee may be able to claim illness benefits from UIF.

Poor work performance despite genuine effort

  1. Set out the standard clearly and show where it isn't being met
  2. Find out why, and give the training, guidance and tools needed
  3. Allow a reasonable time to improve, with regular, documented check-ins
  4. If it still isn't working, consider alternatives such as a different role, then a hearing before any decision

How Scaled handles it

As the legal employer, Scaled runs the process: we gather medical evidence, hold the consultations and keep the records, while you tell us what the role needs and what flexibility you have. Tell us early about long absences or a skills gap, so support can start sooner.

Trusted by growing UK businesses

Second NatureMake My House GreenCurate GroupAtmosclearCreative PodDomaniTTC GroupRibblrLucky Growth PartnersShaded StudiosAKG MediaFixter

Frequently asked questions

Can I dismiss someone for being ill in South Africa?+

Only as a last resort, after investigating, consulting, considering adjustments and allowing reasonable time. Short, genuine illness is covered by sick leave.

Is a performance improvement plan the same as incapacity?+

It's the core of the poor-performance incapacity route: a clear standard, support and time to improve.

Who pays during long-term illness?+

Paid sick leave applies first. After that, leave is unpaid and the employee may claim UIF illness benefits.

Ready to hire world-class South African talent?

No upfront cost. No commitment to kick off a search. Free replacements guaranteed.