HR guide
The disciplinary process in South Africa
If someone isn't performing or has broken a rule, South African law requires a fair disciplinary process before they can be dismissed, including during probation. One size doesn't always fit all: the right steps depend on the issue, the evidence and how long the person has been with you. Below is an example of a process we might follow.
No commitment to kick off a search.
The two tests for a fair dismissal
- Procedural fairness: the person understood what they were accused of, had a real chance to respond, and the decision was taken by someone objective
- Substantive fairness: there was a valid standard, the person knew about it (or reasonably should have), they breached it, and the penalty fits
If a dismissal is referred to the CCMA and the process was unfair, it's treated as unfair regardless of how poor the work was. That's why the process matters so much.
An example disciplinary process
Every case is different, so treat this as an example rather than a fixed rulebook. A typical process is a series of escalating steps, each triggered by a further issue. If things improve, the process stops where it is, but warnings stay on file. Where the issue is a skills gap rather than behaviour, a performance improvement letter may be the better first step: see conduct vs performance.
- Initial written warning: often used in the first 30 days of employment or for minor issues. A meeting, then a letter, live on file for six months. A warning meeting doesn't need advance notice
- Final written warning: a meeting, then a letter that says clearly it's a final warning, live for 12 months. Where the facts support it, we may start here
- Disciplinary hearing: at least 48 hours' written notice with the allegations set out, so the person can prepare. The right to bring a representative applies at the hearing. We chair the hearing and, if the outcome supports it, issue notice of termination
- Exit: the notice period is worked. At least one week in the first six months, two weeks up to a year, and four weeks after that, unless the contract says longer
Example timelines
| Day | Within the first 30 days | After the first 30 days |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | You flag that targets aren't being met | You flag that targets aren't being met |
| 2 | Meeting; initial written warning | Meeting; final written warning |
| 8–9 | Check-in; meeting; final written warning | Check-in; 48 hours' notice; hearing; notice of termination |
| 15–16 | Check-in; 48 hours' notice; hearing; notice of termination | Notice period ends (day 16) |
| 23 | Notice period ends | — |
Indicative. Dates move if the evidence needed to run the process arrives late.
What makes a case strong
- The standard existed and was clear: a KPI sheet, a documented process, a training session or a message setting expectations
- The person knew about it
- It's applied consistently: if two people miss the same target and only one is disciplined, that's a problem
- The breach is proved with specifics. "Unreliable" isn't a case. "Rostered 09:00 start; first call logged at 10:51 on 6 March, per the dialler export" is
- No surprises: everything in a warning letter must have been raised in the meeting first
What we ask of you as a Scaled client
- Tell us early. If you only tell us once you're certain you want someone gone, the exit will take longer
- Complete our performance and conduct record after the first call, and keep it updated
- Put your concerns in writing: a short email saying the work isn't acceptable supports a stronger first step
- Allow a few hours across the whole process for calls and check-ins
You don't need to attend the meetings or the hearing; we attend on your behalf, though you're welcome to join. If the issue is about ability or health rather than conduct, we'll recommend the incapacity route instead.
Trusted by growing UK businesses









Frequently asked questions
Is there one disciplinary process for every case?+
No. One size doesn't always fit all. The steps depend on the issue, the evidence and the person's length of service. The process on this page is an example of what we might follow.
Does probation change the disciplinary process?+
Usually only slightly: notice is shorter, and early in employment we'd normally start with an initial warning rather than a final one.
Does an employee need notice of a warning meeting?+
No. Advance notice and the right to a representative apply to a disciplinary hearing, not to a meeting to issue a warning.
Does the employee have to agree with a warning?+
No. They sign to acknowledge receipt, not agreement.
What if the person says the issue is stress or mental health?+
It doesn't stop the process, but it changes how it's handled. Health-related incapacity needs medical support; if it's supported, we move to sick leave and, if needed, an incapacity process.
What's the worst case if it goes wrong?+
A referral to the CCMA. If the process was unfair, the outcome is usually a settlement of a few weeks' to a few months' pay. Running the process properly keeps that off the table.
Ready to hire world-class South African talent?
No upfront cost. No commitment to kick off a search. Free replacements guaranteed.