HR guide
Misconduct vs poor work performance in South Africa
When a South African employee isn't meeting expectations, the first question is whether it's misconduct or poor work performance. Misconduct is about behavior: a rule or instruction the person knew about and broke. Poor work performance is about ability: a skill that needs developing. The answer decides which letter you start with and how the process runs.
No commitment to kick off a search.
Misconduct vs poor work performance: the difference
| Misconduct | Poor work performance | |
|---|---|---|
| The question | Won't they? | Can't they? |
| Typical examples | Ignoring instructions, poor timekeeping, going offline without telling anyone, rudeness, dishonesty | A skill gap: accuracy, product knowledge or a technique they haven't mastered yet |
| First written step | A warning letter | A performance improvement letter setting out the skills to develop and the support given |
| If it continues | A final warning, then a disciplinary hearing | More support and time, then the incapacity route |
Many cases are a mix. Be clear which issue you're addressing in each conversation and letter, and don't switch between them. See the disciplinary process and incapacity guides for each route.
When missed targets can be treated as misconduct
It's tempting to think that missing a KPI is always a performance issue. It isn't. If the person knows the standard, has been trained, has shown they can meet it and still doesn't, for example by not following the agreed process or mis-prioritizing their work, that can follow the misconduct route.
When you take that route for underperformance, the warning needs to do two extra things:
- Spell out the impact on the business, such as missed meetings, delayed customer replies or lost revenue
- Restate the standard clearly, with the target and how it's measured
If the person is genuinely trying and lacks the skill, use the performance route instead: a performance improvement letter, training and reasonable time to improve.
Start documenting straight away
The most useful habit is to write concerns down as soon as they come up, with dates, examples and the source of any numbers. Catching issues early, and addressing them in writing, means less of the case rests on what's said at a hearing later.
- Note what happened, when, and how you know
- Record what you said to the person and what they said back
- Keep the standard you're measuring against: a KPI sheet, a process document or a message setting expectations
How warning letters escalate
- A first warning letter, or a performance improvement letter for a skills gap
- If the standard still isn't met: a final warning (sometimes called a final terms letter)
- If it continues, or the employee strongly disputes the warning: an enquiry, which is a disciplinary hearing, to decide the outcome
A meeting to issue a warning doesn't need advance notice, and the employee doesn't have a right to bring a representative to it; that right applies at a hearing. Scaled clients can hold an early warning conversation themselves, as long as it's documented properly so we can pick it up if it goes further.
Which route should you choose?
- They've shown they can do it, but aren't: misconduct
- They broke a clear rule or ignored an instruction: misconduct
- They're new, trying hard and still learning: poor work performance
- There's a health issue behind it: incapacity, with medical evidence
- The role itself is no longer needed: neither; that's retrenchment
If you're unsure, tell us before you say anything formal. Through Scaled, we'll agree the right route with you, draft the letters and run any hearing.
Trusted by growing UK businesses









Frequently asked questions
Can poor performance be treated as misconduct in South Africa?+
Sometimes. If the employee knows the standard and can meet it but doesn't, it can follow the misconduct route, as long as the warning sets out the business impact and restates the standard.
What is a performance improvement letter?+
A written letter that sets out the skills that need developing, the support you'll give and a reasonable timeframe. It's the usual first step for genuine poor performance.
Do I need to give notice before a warning meeting?+
No. Notice, and the right to a representative, apply to a disciplinary hearing.
Can I issue a warning myself?+
Scaled clients can hold an early warning conversation, as long as it's documented properly. Talk to us first so the letter is right.
Ready to hire world-class South African talent?
No upfront cost. No commitment to kick off a search. Free replacements guaranteed.